Request a Feature, Bug Report and Suggestion Thread, Blitz Edition!

Comments

  • SheSaidSheSaidSheSaidSheSaid Washed Up
    edited August 2012
    How are people without online access playing the game at all, though?
  • jibjqrkljibjqrkl Eventually Perceptive
    edited August 2012
    SheSaidSheSaid;4859680 said:
    How are people without online access playing the game at all, though?

    some people can't or don't want to be online all the time.
  • SayburrSayburr The Always Informative Rock Band Forum Guru
    edited August 2012
    SheSaidSheSaid;4859680 said:
    How are people without online access playing the game at all, though?

    ....well, I guess they aren't since they have to have online access to download the game in the first place...
  • edited August 2012
    jibjqrkl;4858715 said:
    maybe like a cheat that gives you unlimited coins but no leaderboard scores?

    What about a cheat that gives you leaderboard scores but no coins?
  • SayburrSayburr The Always Informative Rock Band Forum Guru
    edited August 2012
    hmxhenry;4859733 said:
    What about a cheat that gives you leaderboard scores but no coins?
    How many coins do you want for that one?
  • Rock_StarmanRock_Starman Headliner
    edited August 2012
    Would need a Blitz cred cheat to go with it so you can unlock all the powerups. Can't even 5 star songs without them apparently. In a single player console game. Someone comes up with this stuff then someone approves it. I still don't understand how such things happen. Someone at some point needs to say something. I assume it was the same people that took away arena select and tied unlockables to instruments in RB 3. :p

    Watching the video on Giantbomb I'd also suggest freely mappable controls. It doesn't look like you can set it to X and B or X and A,only A and B.
  • Cipher_PeonCipher_Peon I don't get it at all
    edited August 2012
    You'll get all of the powerups in like 20 minutes and then wonder why they had to be locked in the first place.
  • HMXmattitudeHMXmattitude Harmonix Developer
    edited August 2012
    russianbear28;4857090 said:
    Difficulty. The game is way too easy to play. There's only so much you can do with two notes. Besides, when I played Amplitude, it came naturally to me to play with three buttons.

    We playtested three notes per track, and it was cut. Having to deal with too many notes on top of all the various mechanics like track leveling, multipliers, streaking, overdrive, and powerup combos, was overwhelming to testers.
  • Cipher_PeonCipher_Peon I don't get it at all
    edited August 2012
    For some reason I'm kind of, but not really linked to Facebook. I can play Score Wars no problem, but my messages keep telling me to link with FB and on Rock Band World Link, I'm given a code to link...

    I really want to see my shopping cart :I
  • agentnncagentnnc Road Warrior
    edited August 2012
    I would like to request that at the very least the facebook app be integrated into a game interface like the goals menu in RB3 and at the very most remove the requirement for having facebook. Facebook integration makes RBB sound like it's a cheap iPhone app.
  • Cipher_PeonCipher_Peon I don't get it at all
    edited August 2012
    Having Facebook isn't a requirement, it's a recommendation. You can still be competitive without Facebook.

    And trust me, it's not anything like a cheap iPhone app. It adds tons of value. I'm really happy about the FB app since it actually got me to be better friends with the people I was already acquainted with in these forums.
  • spark32spark32 Opening Act
    edited August 2012
    Here's a bug. You can't download the soundtrack unless you load up Rock Band Blitz on the account you purchased it on.
  • agentnncagentnnc Road Warrior
    edited August 2012
    Cipher_Peon;4860047 said:
    Having Facebook isn't a requirement, it's a recommendation. You can still be competitive without Facebook.

    And trust me, it's not anything like a cheap iPhone app. It adds tons of value. I'm really happy about the FB app since it actually got me to be better friends with the people I was already acquainted with in these forums.

    I'll still do it when the xbox version comes out tomorrow. However, there is nothing I've seen on the RBWorld app that can't be converted into a console interface that doesn't require facebook or social media. Grand Theft Auto has been tracking many many stats since the PS2, Bungie had their stats on their own website, RB3 already had battles you could send to friends by console or by this website. Facebook was unnecessary and a deliberate free advertising move.
  • Cipher_PeonCipher_Peon I don't get it at all
    edited August 2012
    Even assuming you know the inner workings of the code for this game and completely ignoring this game's budget (you know, because 15 dollar arcade games totally receive the same amount of money that full blown multi million dollar titles like GTA does), I would ask if there's anything wrong with the Facebook integration.

    Are there things that seem redundant or strange? Of course. There's no denying that. Sending Score Wars is possible through the game, but it's not really fluid, and you can't send Score Wars from people in the leaderboards. That totally does suck. But having Facebook as a social tool in order to promote the game is a fantastic approach to the game's ambitions and target audience. I'm glad that they went with this approach and the game is incredible with it. Is it still amazing without it? Yes. Harmonix can be generally trusted with solid titles. But I'm happy that it's in the game, because if it wasn't, I wouldn't be a part of a fantastic FB group dedicated to this game.
  • edited August 2012
    agentnnc;4860056 said:
    I'll still do it when the xbox version comes out tomorrow. However, there is nothing I've seen on the RBWorld app that can't be converted into a console interface that doesn't require facebook or social media. Grand Theft Auto has been tracking many many stats since the PS2, Bungie had their stats on their own website, RB3 already had battles you could send to friends by console or by this website. Facebook was unnecessary and a deliberate free advertising move.
    GTA, Bungie titles and RB3 were all multimillion dollar disc releases, not XBLA downloadable titles. There are a great many things achievable on disc titles that simply aren't an option with the more limited size and scope of an arcade title. Much of what RB World accomplishes could not have been shoehorned into the game and likely would not have been part of Blitz if we didn't build a companion app to support it.

    As for why we chose Facebook for RB World over doing something similar on this site... we already did that and it was called Rock Band 3 and it was heavily under used. People were put off by linking with the site, Battle creation and difficulty matchmaking. So we turned to Facebook as a platform that eliminated those complaints. Linking is easier on Facebook, Score War creation is even quicker and instead of tapping into a community of ~500K on this site we're able to reach a community of ~3 million on our FB page.

    Also, as far as an advertising move, the Blitz ads currently running on our Facebook page are the only advertising we've ever done there. So unless our plan was to get you to buy Blitz so you would go to Facebook where we tell you to buy Blitz, no this isn't just about advertising.
  • agentnncagentnnc Road Warrior
    edited August 2012
    hmxhenry;4860101 said:
    GTA, Bungie titles and RB3 were all multimillion dollar disc releases, not XBLA downloadable titles. There are a great many things achievable on disc titles that simply aren't an option with the more limited size and scope of an arcade title. Much of what RB World accomplishes could not have been shoehorned into the game and likely would not have been part of Blitz if we didn't build a companion app to support it.

    As for why we chose Facebook for RB World over doing something similar on this site... we already did that and it was called Rock Band 3 and it was heavily under used. People were put off by linking with the site, Battle creation and difficulty matchmaking. So we turned to Facebook as a platform that eliminated those complaints. Linking is easier on Facebook, Score War creation is even quicker and instead of tapping into a community of ~500K on this site we're able to reach a community of ~3 million on our FB page.

    Also, as far as an advertising move, the Blitz ads currently running on our Facebook page are the only advertising we've ever done there. So unless our plan was to get you to buy Blitz so you would go to Facebook where we tell you to buy Blitz, no this isn't just about advertising.

    Fair enough. I didn't think that was the status of the online interface. I thought it was very intuitive and well made. What I had meant by advertising was the potential for the many wall posts saying "You have received/sent a new rock band blitz challenge" or "You have new rock band blitz challenges/goals" which could be plastered all over the walls of those who play often. This would lead to all visitors seeing the post and knowing about the game, causing them to check it out. While it may not be the case for the Rock Band World app, facebook apps in general have bad reputations of doing this, especially those relating to gaming. You guys were with EA and didn't bend your customers over for money and publicity, why start now? I'm sure the right choices were made. I'm just expressing my concern over my general dislike for feeding as much information to facebook as humanly possible.

    As for the Rock Band Facebook page, I would be surprised if you didn't change it to get blitz maximum exposure. Rock Band Blitz is indeed a part of the Rock Band franchise so it deserves the spotlight for a while. I don't check pages on facebook often but I always thought it was the norm to make a page the sole focus of a new product for a few weeks before reverting to a page that shows more or less everything (although I really like the artwork on the page right now).

    Also, thanks for replying. I think it's great that Harmonix takes the time to address community concerns. There are very few developers (if any) that consistently release great games that keep ties with the community.
  • Hogan2000Hogan2000 Banned
    edited August 2012
    I have a big ass bug bruther. I bought the game and downloaded it but it's not showing up on my playstation bruther???
  • edited August 2012
    agentnnc;4860287 said:
    What I had meant by advertising was the potential for the many wall posts saying "You have received/sent a new rock band blitz challenge" or "You have new rock band blitz challenges/goals" which could be plastered all over the walls of those who play often. This would lead to all visitors seeing the post and knowing about the game, causing them to check it out. While it may not be the case for the Rock Band World app, facebook apps in general have bad reputations of doing this, especially those relating to gaming.
    That's totally fair. We actually went out of our way to make sure that RB World never posts anything unless you tell it to. If you complete a Goal and want to post it you can, if you want to brag that you beat your friend in a Score War you can click the handy Brag button we built next to it or you can continue to snipe away at the leaderboards without ever saying a word.

    Some people will want to stay off the radar and others, as we've already seen just in the closed Beta, will want to post trash talk and brag and join friends in finishing Goals and Facebook has all the social hooks you could ever want to make that easy, easier than any site plug in we could create. It's as much or as little as you want it to be.
    agentnnc;4860287 said:
    I'm sure the right choices were made. I'm just expressing my concern over my general dislike for feeding as much information to facebook as humanly possible.
    I completely understand. I have avoided Facebook like the plague and only just created an account this weekend... and I did it for RB World. I have my own privacy and posting concerns, so hopefully if I felt comfortable enough to jump into the pool then that speaks to my level of faith in RB World.
    agentnnc;4860287 said:
    Also, thanks for replying. I think it's great that Harmonix takes the time to address community concerns. There are very few developers (if any) that consistently release great games that keep ties with the community.

    You're more than welcome! We try to respond to as much as we possibly can. We are always welcome to constructive criticism and none of the concerns you've voiced are any different than the concerns we've shared during the course of development. If we can help shed some light on the development process and help folks understand why X does Y then that will only make the community more informed and stronger.
  • SheSaidSheSaidSheSaidSheSaid Washed Up
    edited August 2012
    hmxhenry;4860101 said:
    As for why we chose Facebook for RB World over doing something similar on this site... we already did that and it was called Rock Band 3 and it was heavily under used. People were put off by linking with the site, Battle creation and difficulty matchmaking.
    Sadface :( Because I loved all of that.
    hmxhenry;4860101 said:
    So we turned to Facebook as a platform that eliminated those complaints. Linking is easier on Facebook, Score War creation is even quicker and instead of tapping into a community of ~500K on this site we're able to reach a community of ~3 million on our FB page.
    Grr......the more we're linked together, the more isolated we really are. That's why I disdain social networks. And I know it firsthand. I was sucked into that vortex myself for a few years.

    I mean, I guess I understand it from a business point of view, but it still sucks.

    Facebook is basically the Wal-Mart you can never get away from. Everything starts and ends there, whether anyone likes it or not. Le sigh....fact of life.
  • SheSaidSheSaidSheSaidSheSaid Washed Up
    edited August 2012
    agentnnc;4860287 said:
    Also, thanks for replying. I think it's great that Harmonix takes the time to address community concerns.
    Seconded! It keeps me coming back when there might not be anything else that does.
    agentnnc;4860287 said:
    There are very few developers (if any) that consistently release great games that keep ties with the community.

    Valve maybe?
  • edited August 2012
    SheSaidSheSaid;4860317 said:
    Grr......the more we're linked together, the more isolated we really are. That's why I disdain social networks. And I know it firsthand. I was sucked into that vortex myself for a few years.

    psssst Forums are social networks too!

    I get what you mean, really I do, but I think this is something the majority of people will be fine with. We get to reach a bigger audience, the community has more people to Score War with or team up with on Goals, Facebook has built in tools to help and everyone gets a richer experience. Blitz is, of course, still more than playable without RB World and we had playtesters, PAX East and E3 attendees, press and early code folks going bonkers over the game months before we even announced RB World.

    RB World is meant to be a companion piece, an additional layer if you want it. If you don't want it then you can still play all the songs, post high scores, get all the coins, get all the cred and unlock all the achievements without it. It's very much like the forums in a lot of ways, providing that additional layer to the RB experience for the people interested in getting more out of it.
  • SheSaidSheSaidSheSaidSheSaid Washed Up
    edited August 2012
    hmxhenry;4860326 said:
    psssst Forums are social networks too!

    And I've tried to walk away from here a few times too. It's never worked for more than a few weeks :|
  • SirDavidTLynchSirDavidTLynch Headliner
    edited August 2012
    If privacy is a concern, just create an account, make up all the required information (I think you only need a name and an actual email), and hope that nobody named Dick Hertz will fall victim to identity theft.
  • agentnncagentnnc Road Warrior
    edited August 2012
    hmxhenry;4860326 said:
    psssst Forums are social networks too!

    It seems that the term social networking site means "site that has a decent idea of who I am in real life". You don't have my name, photograph and where I currently work (many employers in my area want this to be displayed before you get a job). Harmonix also doesn't have any information other than email addresses, gamertags and rock band stats that could be sold. So there's no major breach of privacy.
  • jbshredmanjbshredman Unsigned
    edited August 2012
    hmxhenry;4860326 said:
    psssst forums are social networks too!

    exactly.
  • SheSaidSheSaidSheSaidSheSaid Washed Up
    edited August 2012
    SirDavidTLynch;4860364 said:
    If privacy is a concern, just create an account, make up all the required information (I think you only need a name and an actual email), and hope that nobody named Dick Hertz will fall victim to identity theft.

    "Uh, is there a Hugh Jass here? Hugh Jass!"

    "I'm Hugh Jass."

    "Telephone for you."
  • thatmarkguythatmarkguy Road Warrior
    edited August 2012
    So, uh, others playing the PS3 version... are the Coin/Cred screens and Powerup Unlocked screens looking right to you?

    I see from youtube videos from early Xboxers that after a song the screens show as:
    Score -> Coin/Cred -> (Powerup Unlocked if earned) -> Cred-by-instrument-and-genre -> Leaderboards

    Well, for me, the second and third of those screens is graphically screwed. Just unreadable squished and slanted graphics in between the properly-displayed Score screen and the properly-displayed cred-by-instrument screen.

    Am I the only one?
  • Rock_StarmanRock_Starman Headliner
    edited August 2012
    Cipher_Peon;4859885 said:
    You'll get all of the powerups in like 20 minutes and then wonder why they had to be locked in the first place.

    Well no I wouldn't get anything because I wouldn't be online. That was the point of the suggestions. I'd very much like to have the game but as is this won't work and I managed to miss all the contests. :D
  • Bront20Bront20 The Writing's on the Wall
    edited August 2012
    Is it just me? Or can you not submit a score war on Rock Band World yet? It lets me select everything, but there's no way to submit it.
    Cipher_Peon;4859885 said:
    You'll get all of the powerups in like 20 minutes and then wonder why they had to be locked in the first place.
    2 hours later, I still haven't gotten the second track powerup unlocked. I can't get 5 stars on anything either (got really close on 1 song, a few hundred short). I was earning 60 cred per song on a few songs, then it dropped down to 40.
  • Bront20Bront20 The Writing's on the Wall
    edited August 2012
    spark32;4860052 said:
    Here's a bug. You can't download the soundtrack unless you load up Rock Band Blitz on the account you purchased it on.
    Why is that a bug? That's called "Copy Protect"
Sign In or Register to comment.