Official CAKE DLC Thread (Actively Updated!)

Comments

  • frostboy74frostboy74 Opening Act
    edited February 2008
    Not a fan of Cake, but the song "Sheep Go To Heaven" is a classic in my book.
  • TransbrakTransbrak Headliner
    edited February 2008
    Wow this is a really well made thread, I would be up for any cake i could get my hands on.

    pretty pink ribbon is my current favorite though
  • TakeABowTakeABow Road Warrior
    edited February 2008
    My favorite Cake song would have to be Comissioning A Symphony In C.

    Agree with my numbers or not (since you haven't rated the song yet) I would say:

    Guitar: 13 (some downtime, but there is a solo)
    Bass: 14 (Simple, but elegant)
    Drums: 14 (Fun to play **I play this song on real drums)
    Vocals and Lyrics: 14 (Fun, interesting lyrics)
    Overall Quality and Band Energy: 26 (amazing song, but not brimming with energy)
    Misc: 10 (All Rock Band part friendly)

    Totaling this all up we get: 91%
  • Isaac9erIsaac9er Opening Act
    edited February 2008
    "I Will Survive" would be one of the best Bass songs on RockBand. Has my vote. I would love to see Cake on RB.
  • pmpboarderpmpboarder Road Warrior
    edited February 2008
    Hey, thanks for all the compliments on the thread, guys! I'm glad you appreciate the work I put into it. (And it's still not even complete yet!) With all your votes, the Most-Wanted CAKE Songs post is finally taking shape. Let's keep it up!

    Feel free to vote for other additional songs, too! There's no limit to how many votes you can cast, but please keep it reasonable. I understand the "I want EVERY SINGLE CAKE SONG in Rock Band" mentality better than anyone. So if I can refrain, you can, too.

    Thanks, TakeABow, that helps a lot! I'm listening to "Commissioning a Symphony in C" right now, and I have to agree with your numbers. Unless you object, I'm gonna use your breakdown. I'll tweak it a little to match my layout and will give you credit. :cool:
  • Mister_DerpMister_Derp Road Warrior
    edited February 2008
    Wow. I created an account just so I could reply to this thread. Cake would be absolutely PERFECT for Rock Band.
    The Distance
    I Will Survive
    Comfort Eagle
    Stickshifts and Safetybelts
    Short Skirt/Long Jacket
    Shadow Stabbing

    Too many to name. In fact, that would be the only drawback to having Cake DLC. No matter what they pick, there will always be another song that I wish they had put in! I think they can solve this by having every Cake song ever made. :D
  • pmpboarderpmpboarder Road Warrior
    edited February 2008
    Mister_Derp;298639 said:
    Wow. I created an account just so I could reply to this thread. Cake would be absolutely PERFECT for Rock Band.
    The Distance
    I Will Survive
    Comfort Eagle
    Stickshifts and Safetybelts
    Short Skirt/Long Jacket
    Shadow Stabbing

    Too many to name. In fact, that would be the only drawback to having Cake DLC. No matter what they pick, there will always be another song that I wish they had put in! I think they can solve this by having every Cake song ever made. :D
    Haha, thanks! I'm glad this thread could encourage a fellow CAKE fan to create an account! Thanks for your votes, too. Your input is the main reason I created this thread. I'm thrilled to see it so active! I knew I could round all the CAKE fans up. :cool:
  • sandswipesandswipe Rising Star
    edited February 2008
    **** yes.

    My picks for cake pack 01:
    Distance
    Stickshifts and Safety Belts
    Love You Madley

    picks for cake pack 02:
    I will survive
    Sheep go to Heaven
    Let Me Go

    03:
    Shadow Stabbing
    Arco Arena/Comfort Eagle (use AA as an intro, even if it's not supposed to be- only way it'll get in)
    Short Skirt, Long Jacket
    . . .
    . . . .

    picks for cake pack 20:
    Opera Singer
    Daria
    Open Book

    and I don't want HMX to stop until we get to the end.
  • skyking613skyking613 Unsigned
    edited February 2008
    I cant believe I havent seen this thread before.
    Hell yah we need some Cake in RB.
    I absolutelly love cake too. I have been asking for Cake since I got Rock Band.
  • pmpboarderpmpboarder Road Warrior
    edited February 2008
    sandswipe;304391 said:
    **** yes.

    My picks for cake pack 01:
    Distance
    Stickshifts and Safety Belts
    Love You Madley

    picks for cake pack 02:
    I will survive
    Sheep go to Heaven
    Let Me Go

    03:
    Shadow Stabbing
    Arco Arena/Comfort Eagle (use AA as an intro, even if it's not supposed to be- only way it'll get in)
    Short Skirt, Long Jacket
    . . .
    . . . .

    picks for cake pack 20:
    Opera Singer
    Daria
    Open Book

    and I don't want HMX to stop until we get to the end.
    Major win for that post. And thanks for the votes. That's a great idea with "Arco Arena" as an intro to "Comfort Eagle"! I never thought of that before, but it's perfect, and is indeed the only way it could get in the game. Unless Harmonix can get their hands on "Arco Arena (Vocal Version)"... :cool:
    skyking613;304469 said:
    I cant believe I havent seen this thread before.
    Hell yah we need some Cake in RB.
    I absolutelly love cake too. I have been asking for Cake since I got Rock Band.
    Better late than never! Thanks for finding it and sharing your thoughts. ;)
  • em3rica89em3rica89 Opening Act
    edited February 2008
    This band sucks. I would like to see Tool in rock band.
  • BAntboyBAntboy Unsigned
    edited February 2008
    Seriously though, I'd LOVE to have some Cake in Rock Band. I can't say I'm a hard core fan, but over the past 10+ years, they've put out some great stuff, and sandswipe's suggestions for Cake Packs sounds perfect.

    I'd buy all 3 of those in a heartbeat.
  • pmpboarderpmpboarder Road Warrior
    edited February 2008
    BAntboy;306071 said:
    Seriously though, I'd LOVE to have some Cake in Rock Band. I can't say I'm a hard core fan, but over the past 10+ years, they've put out some great stuff, and sandswipe's suggestions for Cake Packs sounds perfect.

    I'd buy all 3 of those in a heartbeat.
    Awesome. :cool:

    He actually had 4 packs, though. So, just to be clear, do you mind listing the songs again, so I can officially tally your votes? Thanks.
  • pinkbrassmonkeypinkbrassmonkey Opening Act
    edited February 2008
    i just love this thread. i heard 'i will survive' in my friends car on sirius, and it was crazy good. needs to be in rock band. i'm gonna look into more songs by them now.
  • an1m051tyan1m051ty Rising Star
    edited February 2008
    sandswipe;304391 said:
    **** yes.

    My picks for cake pack 01:
    Distance
    Stickshifts and Safety Belts
    Love You Madley

    picks for cake pack 02:
    I will survive
    Sheep go to Heaven
    Let Me Go

    03:
    Shadow Stabbing
    Arco Arena/Comfort Eagle (use AA as an intro, even if it's not supposed to be- only way it'll get in)
    Short Skirt, Long Jacket
    . . .
    . . . .

    picks for cake pack 20:
    Opera Singer
    Daria
    Open Book

    and I don't want HMX to stop until we get to the end.
    I think at this point you'd be looking in Guitar Hero's direction....I hear they are the ones that devote entire game entries to one band (in case you haven't heard, one of the three or so GH games coming out this year is all about Aerosmith). But, to that end, at least it would be cheaper by a lot!:D
  • pmpboarderpmpboarder Road Warrior
    edited February 2008
    pinkbrassmonkey;314590 said:
    i just love this thread. i heard 'i will survive' in my friends car on sirius, and it was crazy good. needs to be in rock band. i'm gonna look into more songs by them now.
    Thank you! I'm thrilled to see this thread encourage you to check out more of their music instead of voting for the third option in the poll! And I agree - "I Will Survive" is, as you say, "crazy good." :cool:

    If you need suggestions on songs to listen to (for the sake of listening, not necessarily Rock Band compatibility), let me know!
    an1m051ty;314621 said:
    I think at this point you'd be looking in Guitar Hero's direction....I hear they are the ones that devote entire game entries to one band (in case you haven't heard, one of the three or so GH games coming out this year is all about Aerosmith). But, to that end, at least it would be cheaper by a lot!:D
    Haha, that's a good point. But then, look at The Police. In a couple hours, the 5th song of theirs is gonna be in Rock Band. Then one more next month, if that schedule remains unchanged.

    I'm not saying it's likely CAKE would receive the same amount of attention (or sales) The Police get, but with full albums coming out, some bands are gonna get lucky.
  • smoomoo31smoomoo31 Unsigned
    edited February 2008
    Wow, you sure did go into great detail. I appreciate the hard work! My girlfriend probably would explode if Cake was released as DLC.
  • pmpboarderpmpboarder Road Warrior
    edited February 2008
    smoomoo31;314729 said:
    Wow, you sure did go into great detail. I appreciate the hard work! My girlfriend probably would explode if Cake was released as DLC.
    Haha, well, we wouldn't want her to explode. I haven't thought about what would happen to me if and when CAKE gets some DLC... :rolleyes: Anyway, you should ask her what CAKE songs she'd like to see the most! Her votes are as good as anyone registered for the site, as you'd buy them for her and she would play them!

    Also, thanks. It has taken a lot of work, and I'm still not done. I've run out of room in all the posts, so now I've gotta figure out how I can merge the list I've made with the list determined by the votes... :confused:
  • smoomoo31smoomoo31 Unsigned
    edited February 2008
    I'll see what she wants!
  • smokeverbssmokeverbs Opening Act
    edited February 2008
    3 Million kudos for this thread, and the thoroughness of it, but what would we do with the horns?
  • AbaddonAbaddon Road Warrior
    edited February 2008
    smokeverbs;314775 said:
    3 Million kudos for this thread, and the thoroughness of it, but what would we do with the horns?
    Same thing we do with the keyboards in Won't Get Fooled Again --- listen and enjoy :D

    I would love to see a Cake three-pack:

    The Distance
    I Will Survive
    Guitar

    I mean, more than a three-pack would be great too, but probably unrealistic.

    [EDIT] Forgot to add, there is already a Chico band (Mother Hips) in Rock Band so there should really be a Sactown band represented too.
  • pmpboarderpmpboarder Road Warrior
    edited February 2008
    Abaddon;318847 said:
    Same thing we do with the keyboards in Won't Get Fooled Again --- listen and enjoy :D

    I would love to see a Cake three-pack:

    The Distance
    I Will Survive
    Guitar

    I mean, more than a three-pack would be great too, but probably unrealistic.
    "Listen and enjoy" -- Great answer! I like that. :cool: Thanks for the votes! Looks like "The Distance" and "I Will Survive" are the two everyone wants! It's a little too early to tell, with only 9 votes for each, but still. The next song ("Sheep Go To Heaven") has 7 votes.

    Tell all your CAKE-loving friends! We need more votes!
  • FlameSama1FlameSama1 Road Warrior
    edited February 2008
    I'd like to see Short Skirt, Long Jacket and Never There as singles in Rock Band.
  • pmpboarderpmpboarder Road Warrior
    edited February 2008
    FlameSama1;318920 said:
    I'd like to see Short Skirt, Long Jacket and Never There as singles in Rock Band.
    Nice. Both of those are at the very top of my list, too. :cool:
  • greatghandigreatghandi Unsigned
    edited February 2008
    Signed up just to say The Distance would rock out my face! :cool:

    Could anyone who's been on these boards for a while give me an idea of how seriously Harmonix takes these suggestions?
  • TakeABowTakeABow Road Warrior
    edited February 2008
    They read the boards, and they take suggestions seriously. But they have a long / difficult process to get a song from the idea phase to DLC. This involves finding a multi-track master recording, signing deals with record companies and the artist, and then programming it for the game, 4 instruments, 4 difficulties, plus animations and then checking for bugs. Somewhere it was said to be a 3-6 month process overall. If we keep pushing, and/or contact Cake themselves, it will probably happen eventually.

    Emailing Cake and telling them how much we love their music, how we want to play it in rock band can't hurt at all.
  • pmpboarderpmpboarder Road Warrior
    edited February 2008
    greatghandi;319956 said:
    Signed up just to say The Distance would rock out my face! :cool:

    Could anyone who's been on these boards for a while give me an idea of how seriously Harmonix takes these suggestions?
    Thanks! It's so cool seeing all these new members claiming they're joining just to post in this thread. Makes the time I've spent on it seem worthwhile. As do all the posts. ;)
    TakeABow;319995 said:
    They read the boards, and they take suggestions seriously. But they have a long / difficult process to get a song from the idea phase to DLC. This involves finding a multi-track master recording, signing deals with record companies and the artist, and then programming it for the game, 4 instruments, 4 difficulties, plus animations and then checking for bugs. Somewhere it was said to be a 3-6 month process overall. If we keep pushing, and/or contact Cake themselves, it will probably happen eventually.

    Emailing Cake and telling them how much we love their music, how we want to play it in rock band can't hurt at all.
    That's great insight! I couldn't have said it better myself. I did send an email to CAKE's manager, but haven't heard anything back (not did I really expect to). All I'm doing is planting the seed. :)
  • greatghandigreatghandi Unsigned
    edited February 2008
    TakeABow;319995 said:
    They read the boards, and they take suggestions seriously. But they have a long / difficult process to get a song from the idea phase to DLC. This involves finding a multi-track master recording, signing deals with record companies and the artist, and then programming it for the game, 4 instruments, 4 difficulties, plus animations and then checking for bugs. Somewhere it was said to be a 3-6 month process overall. If we keep pushing, and/or contact Cake themselves, it will probably happen eventually.

    Emailing Cake and telling them how much we love their music, how we want to play it in rock band can't hurt at all.
    Good suggestions, i'm gonna fire off these emails tonight. :)
  • TakeABowTakeABow Road Warrior
    edited February 2008
    Here is the thread where the DLC process is explained in depth.

    With the success of DLC so far (2.5 million dowloads) artists that were less inclined to sign contracts with MTV games will probably allow thier songs in the game. What would be ideal is if bands actually actively approached MTV to get songs into the game. I can only hope we get to this point.

    Reluctantly crouched, at the starting line...
  • pmpboarderpmpboarder Road Warrior
    edited February 2008
    TakeABow;321936 said:
    Reluctantly crouched, at the starting line...
    Engines pumping and thumping in time... :cool:
Sign In or Register to comment.