The Unofficial Coheed and Cambria Request Thread (Part III)

Comments

  • Xero314-2Xero314-2 Rising Star
    edited August 2008
    I just realized that now that HMX as shown that instrumentals, which I assume would also allow missing other instruments, are acceptable it's possible to get any of the Coheed albums in their entirety. I assume they would still combine shorter tracks, but now the longer tracks that are missing an instrument should be able to be released.
  • ULS_980ULS_980 Rising Star
    edited August 2008
    Xero314-2;1077035 said:
    I just realized that now that HMX as shown that instrumentals, which I assume would also allow missing other instruments, are acceptable it's possible to get any of the Coheed albums in their entirety. I assume they would still combine shorter tracks, but now the longer tracks that are missing an instrument should be able to be released.
    "Always & Never" is drum-less, right?
    Ugh... that's the only song off of Good Apollo 1 that I just cannot stand...
    Either way, I'd still buy Good Apollo 1 in it's entirety if they released it. :P
  • ZeleniaZelenia Unsigned
    edited August 2008
    ZOMG YAY, it's STILL on the first page! Ha! XD I've been gone for a long time...I was expecting the thread to have drifted away into nothingland by now. But, I logged in and here it is, STILL at the top. There's no way HMX can ignore this. I mean, come on. A few more months and it'll be a year since it started.

    Thanks, DarkEternal, for picking up all that slack I left hanging around all over the place. XD

    I do have a suggestion, though. In the stats section, where it lists the last two threads, can they link to the others?

    Thread 1: http://www.rockband.com/forums/showthread.php?t=28344
    Thread 2: http://www.rockband.com/forums/showthread.php?t=35297

    That way, people can go and see everything that's happened right from the beginning. ^.^
  • xX51NN3RXxxX51NN3RXx Unsigned
    edited August 2008
    Maybe 2-3 songs from each album?

    SSTB
    Time Consumer
    Delirium Trigger
    Devil in Jersey City

    IKSoSE:3
    In Keeping Secrets of Silent Earth: 3
    Blood Red Summer
    A Favor House Atlantic
    The Crowing

    GAV1:FFTtEoM

    The Suffering
    Crossing the Frame
    The Final Cut

    I love the whole Good Apollo Vol. 2 album, so I can't choose which ones to put in lmao.
  • ForgottenHeroForgottenHero Road Warrior
    edited August 2008
    Oh man since when is there a part three!? I've been way outta the loop!

    suscribed....
  • ZeleniaZelenia Unsigned
    edited August 2008
    ForgottenHero;1077700 said:
    Oh man since when is there a part three!? I've been way outta the loop!

    suscribed....
    Me too. XD
  • ForgottenHeroForgottenHero Road Warrior
    edited August 2008
    Well I was part of the second thread and I thought I hadn't viewed the thread recently and no wonder why! Theres a whole new one lol.
  • Xero314-2Xero314-2 Rising Star
    edited August 2008
    ULS_980;1077307 said:
    "Always & Never" is drum-less, right?
    Ugh... that's the only song off of Good Apollo 1 that I just cannot stand...
    Either way, I'd still buy Good Apollo 1 in it's entirety if they released it. :P
    I believe Always & Never is just guitar and vocals, and I can't understand how you don't like that song. Regardless of personal tastes (I really like Always & Never) it's important to the story line, so would be required for any complete album release (though Keeping the Blade is probably still out)
  • fatalvendettafatalvendetta Rising Star
    edited August 2008
    I really do think that we're going to get a Coheed album this year, and it will be one of the six albums announced this month. The six albums CAN'T all be bands Harmonix have boners for, so at least one or two have to be fan-requested. Since we know Claudio is really for having more CoCa in Rock Band I think Harmonix might have a whole album ready soon. Three of my guesses for full album DLC is Coheed and Cambria, Muse, and Metallica.
  • ULS_980ULS_980 Rising Star
    edited August 2008
    Xero314-2;1077945 said:
    I believe Always & Never is just guitar and vocals, and I can't understand how you don't like that song. Regardless of personal tastes (I really like Always & Never) it's important to the story line, so would be required for any complete album release (though Keeping the Blade is probably still out)
    I can't give you a better answer of why I don't like the song other than I just don't like it. :P
    Never did like it, never will. It's the only song on that album that I consistantly skip (I sometimes skip Keeping the Blade just to get to Welcome Home faster :P).

    Out of all the Coheed albums I have (Still missing SSTB, probably going to pick it up this weekend), it's the only song I skip. :(
  • ULS_980ULS_980 Rising Star
    edited August 2008
    fatalvendetta;1079699 said:
    I really do think that we're going to get a Coheed album this year, and it will be one of the six albums announced this month. The six albums CAN'T all be bands Harmonix have boners for, so at least one or two have to be fan-requested. Since we know Claudio is really for having more CoCa in Rock Band I think Harmonix might have a whole album ready soon. Three of my guesses for full album DLC is Coheed and Cambria, Muse, and Metallica.
    I cannot see two of the albums being occupied by two bands that are from the same time period and genre (Coheed and Muse, both recent bands, both Progressive Rock).

    Metallica though... is almost a given. :P
  • SteveoKnievoSteveoKnievo Road Warrior
    edited August 2008
    ULS_980;1079873 said:
    I cannot see two of the albums being occupied by two bands that are from the same time period and genre (Coheed and Muse, both recent bands, both Progressive Rock).

    Metallica though... is almost a given. :P
    I agree. I'm thinking we're either going to get Master of Puppets or Kill Em' All. Also I'm predicting Lynyrd Skynyrd's Second Helping, we haven't seen much of them in a while and they got some big hits on that record. Anyways, I'm not sure if we'd see a Coheed album announced as one of the six, but it's definitely on it's way sooner or later.
  • ZeleniaZelenia Unsigned
    edited August 2008
    Alright, I've updated the signature list, because there's apparently been a lot of people left out. I've uploaded an excel file of the list.

    Clicky!
  • SteveoKnievoSteveoKnievo Road Warrior
    edited August 2008
    Zelenia;1081894 said:
    Alright, I've updated the signature list, because there's apparently been a lot of people left out. I've uploaded an excel file of the list.

    Clicky!
    Could you please just tell me how many sigs there are, I'm cheap and don't have excel
  • WhosyodaddehWhosyodaddeh Rising Star
    edited August 2008
    I have a feeling Coheed is going to be one of the 6 albums as well. I mean, they made Welcome Home the new song for the Rock Band commercial.... obviously Coheed has done something great for rock band.
  • chukapriestchukapriest Unsigned
    edited August 2008
    Here's another name for your list (and another post for your thread). It's amazing what these guys are capable of: ardent storytelling, powerful musicianship, outstanding stage performances. They deserve the limelight, if anyone does. Let's see some CO&CA album dlc. I started with IKS, and the tracks Cuts Marked in the March of Men, The Crowing, and 21:13 were mind-blowing. If not that album, their newest would be an excellent choice. No World for Tomorrow gives me shivers every time I hear it, Gravemakers & Gunslingers rocks my world, and The End Complete is epic. And if I could pick just one song to appear in Rock Band, it would have to be the soulful, yet haunting Final Cut. I don't do much of the vocals, so I wouldn't mind the lack of words (through most of the song), just bring on the guitars!
  • BojangleBojangle Opening Act
    edited August 2008
    I too think one of the six albums will be a Coheed album, or a 'Best Of...'. I'd personally prefer an album as that means more chance of another album DLC at a later point.

    I'd be happy with any album really, but I'd be most pleased with In Keeping Secrets of Silent Earth: 3 or Second Stage Turbine Blade. I wouldn't complain about any Coheed DLC, frankly. We're long overdue some!
  • xdarkstarrxxdarkstarrx Unsigned
    edited August 2008
    I am torn between a full Coheed album, or a best of trackpack. I have favorite songs from every CD, ones I hope to God see light of day on Rockband, so if they did a Coheed album, alot of my favorite jams wouldn't make it. Here are my faves from each CD (for rockband I mean)

    Second Stage Turbine Blade:

    Devil in Jersey City
    Delirium Trigger
    Neverender

    In Keeping Secrets of Silent Earth III:

    Title Track ^^^^ (such an epic song)
    The Crowing (pure epic emotion)
    A Favor House Atlantic (Duh...)

    Good Apollo I'm Burning Star IV: Fear Through The Eyes of Madness:

    Crossing the Frame
    The Suffering
    The Willing Well IV: The Final Cut (This is a MUST for DLC, Guitars=amazing)

    GAIBSIV: No World For Tomorrow:

    No World For Tomorrow
    Feathers
    Gravemakers and Gunslingers

    So those are my top 3 picks for DLC from each album. A 12 pack isn't asking for too much is it?!?!?
  • toad3000toad3000 Road Warrior
    edited August 2008
    We're way overdue for more Coheed & Cambria DLC. Just hoping the next track we get isn't a master of Ten Speed. ;)
    But seriously, I played Ten Speed again last night for the first time in months and really wondered why we haven't seen more DLC from this band. Hopefully HMX is able to get masters and get us at least a 3-pack in the near future. If I had to pick just three of their songs, they would probably be:
    The Suffering
    A Favor House Atlantic
    Gravemakers & Gunslingers
  • Thom1234Thom1234 Road Warrior
    edited August 2008
    toad3000;1089207 said:
    We're way overdue for more Coheed & Cambria DLC. Just hoping the next track we get isn't a master of Ten Speed. ;)
    But seriously, I played Ten Speed again last night for the first time in months and really wondered why we haven't seen more DLC from this band. Hopefully HMX is able to get masters and get us at least a 3-pack in the near future. If I had to pick just three of their songs, they would probably be:
    The Suffering
    A Favor House Atlantic
    Gravemakers & Gunslingers
    Agreed. Although I remember reading a thread in which someone said that HMX hadn't contacted C&C in a while. I can't remember which, but I'm sure you could find it with a search.
    Also, IIRC, Ten Speed's master was unusable because the multiple guitars were on a single track. I hope I'm wrong, as I'd gladly buy the master.
    More Coheed and Cambria for Rock Band!!!
  • BojangleBojangle Opening Act
    edited August 2008
    toad3000;1089207 said:
    If I had to pick just three of their songs, they would probably be:
    The Suffering
    A Favor House Atlantic
    Gravemakers & Gunslingers
    This is why Coheed are so great in my opinion. I wouldn't pick those three, no way in hell. Not because their bad songs, I love 'em, it's just they have better songs in my opinion, yet I'd still buy the pack and enjoy it loads.

    The Crowing
    In Keeping Secrets of Silent Earth: 3
    Everything Evil

    Would be my three. :)
  • ioGooseoiioGooseoi Opening Act
    edited August 2008
    I vote for a Neverender pack... yeah thats right I want it all!! lol

    If I had to pick three it would be

    1. Time Consumer (the first song I heard from them and it was love at first listen)
    2. In Keeping Secrets of Silent Earth: 3
    3. NWFT

    Man that was so hard... I mean seriously try to pick just three Coheed songs. All you can think about are the ones you are leaving out. I love me some coheed!
  • WhosyodaddehWhosyodaddeh Rising Star
    edited August 2008
    My 3 songs would be the exact same as Goose, Time consumer is just amazing... first song on the first album they ever made. In Keeping secrets... I dont think I even have to say anything, its literally the most amazing song I have ever heard in my life. When Coheed played In Keeping secrets live a few weeks ago, it was no joke the highlight of my life <_<.

    When they restarted the song at the last minute, and I knew that fateful "MAN YOUR OWN, JACKHAMMER!!!!" was coming, the entire freaking crowd was counting down with their fingers from 3 -> 0 and screamed the loudest chant I have ever heard in my life... it was no joke mind-blowing.

    NWFT... just wow for this game, every single part of it would be amazing. I can just imagine now playing expert guitar and doing that insane beginning part lol... jesus.

    the final cut would be good... but honestly I think other songs should be chosen first, I mean... we are already getting YYZ which has no vocals... and final cut would be kinda close to the same haha.

    Aside from those 3, I would also be insanely happy with Favor house atlantic, simply because its so fun and catchy and would be fun to play... but nah, Goose's 3 songs would be the best no doubt.

    PLEASE HARMONIX! FOR THE LOVE OF GOD JUST GIVE US SOME COHEED PLEASE!!! YOU MADE WELCOME HOME THE SONG FOR THE COMMERCIAL..... OBVIOUSLY COHEED HAS BEEN MAKING AN IMPACT!!!! lol :(!!!!!

    I dont see NiN and Rush being the song played in the newer commercial, so why the hell are they getting like 10 songs on the game when Coheed has only gotten 1 cover :(....
  • trogdor0071trogdor0071 Unsigned
    edited August 2008
    My favorite songs from each album, excluding TSSBT (I could never get into that one)

    --In Keeping Secrets of Silent Earth: 3--
    ~ In Keeping Secrets of Silent Earth: 3
    ~ The Velourium Camper III: Al the Killer (Or Camper Velourium, I have the original CD)
    ~ 2113

    --Good Apollo I'm Burning Star IV: Fear Through The Eyes of Madness--
    ~ Ten Speed (Of God's Blood and Burial) --Not a Cover--
    ~ The Willing Well II: Fear Through The Eyes of Madness
    ~ The Willing Well IV: The Final Cut

    --No World for Tomorrow--
    ~ No World for Tomorrow
    ~ The End Chapter-III: The End Complete
    ~ The End Chapter-IV: On the Brink

    Those would be my picks for a "Best Of" album, but I'd be happy with anything.

    Gotta say though, The End Complete just may be my favorite song. At the start of "GOD, He will not save you!" Best part ever.
  • Setsu102Setsu102 Rising Star
    edited August 2008
    Hopefully we'll get some more Coheed to coincide with the Neverender concerts. I can't wait! I'm going to the In Keeping Secrets one at the Riviera in Chicago.
  • Kevin7979Kevin7979 Unsigned
    edited August 2008
    YES! I want more Coheed and Cambria. I've been hoping that they announce No World For Tomorrow as an album release. Start to finish it's one of the best albums I've heard. Please HMX, announce it!

    Otherwise, some singles I'd love are The Crowing, Keeping Secrets of Silent Earth, Light and Glass or 2113. That's of course in addition to NWFT album release.
  • ShadowWolf97ShadowWolf97 Unsigned
    edited August 2008
    NWFT would be an amazing album (I'm going to go see that part of the Chicago Neverender!), they could combine the Reaping and NWFT into one longer song, since the Reaping leads into NWFT(song) so well, and is otherwise so short. I'm sure some people wouldn't like that though.

    If I had to just do a top 3 I would choose:

    Feathers (fun parts, all around, guitar would be a little repetitive, but whatever, haha)

    A Favor House Atlantic

    The Crowing

    Alternates would be:
    Gravemakers & Gunslingers, 2113, IKSSE3, NWFT, any of the Velorium Campers, Three Evils (i'm a big fan of the whole IKSSE3 album, if you didn't notice, haha), and pretty much every other song they have ever made. Coheed deserves a lot more than the two songs they have now.
  • XJ220_ShroomXJ220_Shroom Unsigned
    edited August 2008
    Gimme more, for sure!!!
  • CubecubedCubecubed Washed Up
    edited August 2008
    ShadowWolf97;1093950 said:
    NWFT would be an amazing album (I'm going to go see that part of the Chicago Neverender!), they could combine the Reaping and NWFT into one longer song, since the Reaping leads into NWFT(song) so well, and is otherwise so short. I'm sure some people wouldn't like that though.

    If I had to just do a top 3 I would choose:

    Feathers (fun parts, all around, guitar would be a little repetitive, but whatever, haha)

    A Favor House Atlantic

    The Crowing

    Alternates would be:
    Gravemakers & Gunslingers, 2113, IKSSE3, NWFT, any of the Velorium Campers, Three Evils (i'm a big fan of the whole IKSSE3 album, if you didn't notice, haha), and pretty much every other song they have ever made. Coheed deserves a lot more than the two songs they have now.
    also Feathers wud rule on drums
  • RockBandRockerRockBandRocker Love Is A Battleship
    edited August 2008
    Why can't I kill "Feathers"?

    That just would not be a good Rock Band song.

    Maybe if we get the full No World For Tomorrow album, but as a SINGLE, I don't think it would be a good choice.

    I think we need to get the epic songs like "The Crowing", "In Keeping Secrets Of Silent Earth: 3", "The End Complete" (Suite = All Parts), "The Willing Well" (Suite), "The Camper Velourium" (Suite)", "The Suffering" (it's close to 6 minutes), etc.

    The guitar work there (^) would maybe change minds and get MORE people into Co&Ca.

    I don't see "Feathers" being able to do that.
Sign In or Register to comment.